Great review! But a misguided watch in my opinion...

Mar 23, 2013,17:14 PM
 

Just because there is a bit of DNA in a concept does not mean that that DNA is a positive point. After having copied each other to oblivion and exhausted the possibilities of tourbillions, watch makers are now going back to the past to see what they can relaunch that wasn't done properly then, for technological or commercial reasons. Some designs certainly deserve a second chance. But I would not wear this watch if you gave me one for free. It's unsightly, it just is, whatever the little oversized block of metal may hold. It's too big, too clunky-looking, and for that money there are watches around that are perhaps less unconventional, but more wearable, and, crucially, show more of the mechanics involved. What this watch needs is a make-over, one that allows the user to see what goes on inside. That would make up for the giant size, the price and the chintzy colour. Give me one that shows the mechanics inside, and I'll wear it.


But I loved reading your review. 

Many thanks,

R

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

My view on the Romain Jerome Spacecraft

 
 By: foversta : March 2nd, 2013-00:20
Foreword: the pictured watch is a prototype and some details will change like the readability of the hours display. It had to happen: after having put invaders and aliens on the dials or having walked on the Moon, Manuel Emch has transformed his last watc...  
login to reply

Congrats Fx!

 
 By: andrewluff : March 2nd, 2013-00:48
Its a great piece and will be a wonderful addition to your collection! I actually loved the watch and I thought e strap was really great on it. Only negative (but was told as a proto and ould be better on production) was the very sharp corners on the base... 
login to reply

Thanks Andrew!

 
 By: foversta : March 2nd, 2013-03:06
And I can't wait to have it on my wrist! Fx
login to reply

This watch is a success on so many levels....

 
 By: moc : March 2nd, 2013-04:27
It manages to legitimise RJ after years of bad perception of the brand. Manuel Emch managed to slowly build brick by brick a serious profile to a brand that was left in ruins ...so Bravo to Mr Emch.... Obviously the aim of the brand is not to compete with... 
login to reply

Thanks a lot Mo for your wise words!

 
 By: foversta : March 3rd, 2013-14:03
And thanks for the discussion we had in Geneva around this topic! You played a big role in the decision... like the DB10 do you remember? ;) Fx
login to reply

Very happy for you, Fx. you so often wrote articles on original watches

 
 By: amanico : March 3rd, 2013-14:06
That it was time for you to get one of them! Bravo, and congratulations. Best, Nicolas
login to reply

Thanks Nicolas! But the hardest part is just starting...

 
 By: foversta : March 3rd, 2013-14:26
I have to wait two months to get it! Funny point: I met a friend yesterday who told me that he also bought it. Fx
login to reply

A bit of wait will enhance your pleasure, Fx. ;)

 
 By: amanico : March 3rd, 2013-17:09
login to reply

Of course I do...

 
 By: moc : March 4th, 2013-02:46
I am glad to be a little part of the experience....after all we are left with good memories..... Well done again.. Mo
login to reply

Congratulations! I am concerned about the hour and minutes...

 
 By: Ronald Held : March 2nd, 2013-16:09
not being in the same plane for reading.
login to reply

Thanks Ronald!

 
 By: foversta : March 3rd, 2013-14:01
I will tell you once the watch will be on my wrist! Fx
login to reply

Wow! Congrats Fx!

 
 By: fernando : March 3rd, 2013-03:19
I am really surprised at this sudden turn in direction when compared to your conservative past history in watch collecting. This piece is quite futuristic IMO and even a bit daring relative to other non-conformist designs. It must have really impressed yo... 
login to reply

Thanks Fernando for your nice words!

 
 By: foversta : March 3rd, 2013-14:01
You know, it is not that surprising for me to take the plunge: I love the daring designs. The trouble is the price of the watches I love like the Urwerk 202... The two months with the UR-202 on my wrist were my best horological souvenir... This time, the ...  
login to reply

Congratulations. I love the ...

 
 By: AndrewD : March 3rd, 2013-13:11
... straight on view of the face. It really does look like a 70's spaceship from Lost in Space or Space 1999. Some of my favourite television memories. I look forward to hearing more when it is on your wrist. Regards Andrew
login to reply

Thanks Andrew !

 
 By: foversta : March 3rd, 2013-13:55
Yes, it's true, I can't wait to have it on my wrist! But sadly, I think that I will have to wait till Baselworld! Fx
login to reply

Congrats on that exclusive timepiece.

 
 By: VMM : March 4th, 2013-01:38
Hi, Nice watch, I kinda like it. An unsual design that reminds me, as you already said, of Darth Vader and Optimus Prime. I also can see some kind of Pandora's box, or the Hellraiser one, where the evil lives. It looks like you can push a lever to release... 
login to reply

Thanks Vicente for your kind words!

 
 By: foversta : March 4th, 2013-13:07
I hope to be able to show it to you in Spain! Fx
login to reply

Congrats Alex! And I met another client last saturday...

 
 By: foversta : March 4th, 2013-13:08
We are at least 3! ;) Fx
login to reply

two other very well known members of the WIS comminity have also

 
 By: alex : March 5th, 2013-02:39
ordered one!
login to reply

I feel like

 
 By: sybelite : March 5th, 2013-08:52
the watch is to big and does not have any curviture to the wrist, like its just sitting on the wrist to large. The numbers are very difficult to read. I wish I could afford the MB&F, that would be the one I get, the ability to lift the parts on the ba... 
login to reply

Congratulations Fx

 
 By: aldossari_faisal : March 6th, 2013-01:46
such a piece of art which one cant be insouciance about the beauty of it, the roots of seventies when they craved for a new time display methods but technology was not much of a help as it is now a days . Faisal
login to reply

Great review! But a misguided watch in my opinion...

 
 By: Poktori : March 23rd, 2013-17:14
Just because there is a bit of DNA in a concept does not mean that that DNA is a positive point. After having copied each other to oblivion and exhausted the possibilities of tourbillions, watch makers are now going back to the past to see what they can r... 
login to reply

Congratulations François-Xavier !

 
 By: p@trice : April 19th, 2013-21:47
login to reply