It depends on how you want the watch serviced

Sep 21, 2016,21:20 PM
 

Do you want to honor the history/sentimentality of the watch, keeping it as original as possible?  Or, do you want to be more aggressive with a service and have a watch that is "newer" (manufacturer's guarantee, water resistance, etc.)?  Both have their pros and cons.

If you go through the Rolex service center, be prepared for an expensive and extensive repair.  Rolex overhauls start at $600 here in the US, but steps up to $800 or even $1000 on vintage calibers.  This is assuming that your watch has a caliber that Rolex still has parts available for.  I think there's a chance that your movement is no longer supported by them (what caliber is it?).  Keep in mind that Rolex is VERY conservative when it comes to replacing parts.  If they see potential functional issues with parts like the crystal, dial, or hands (moisture spotting, lume damage, scratches, discoloration), they will most likely require those parts be replaced.  If the condition is good (and your watch appears to fall in that category), they can reuse them.  Also note that Rolex includes refinishing of the case as part of their service, so if you want to maintain the original look - request that the case not be touched.  Despite all these cautionary notes, Rolex is very efficient.  They are faster than many other manufacturers on service turn-around times, pricing is fair, they do consistently good work, and I can easily recommend them for overhauls on their modern watches. 

Going with an independent gives you flexibility.  Independent watchmakers can go over each of the steps needed to service your watch and are usually very willing to discuss options and advantages/disadvantages.  If again the caliber still has parts readily available from Rolex, any watchmaker with a Rolex parts account should be able to do a good overhaul at exactly the level of service you want.  If parts are discontinued, then hopefully the watchmaker has a stockpile of parts on hand or can get access to them.  Just like the notion of buying the seller when buying used watches, you'll want to gauge a watchmaker on the quality of their work, their support for any subsequent issues, and not just price.  Vintage repairs through independents can take longer (think several months vs. several weeks for Rolex), but you get a much more personal experience.

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Looking to service my dad's Rolex purchased in 1957

 
 By: dominic.salter : September 21st, 2016-06:22
I would appreciate some assistance. My dad gave me his Rolex which was purchased in 1957. It hasn't been service for 40 years but it is working fine. The hands could do with a relume. Should I contact Rolex or find an independent servicer? Are you able to...  

Hi-- a little beauty you have there.

 
 By: pastaboy1939 : September 21st, 2016-06:31
First don't relume hands or anything on dial. Don't polish the case and don't let Rolex touch it. These things will decrease the value. Use a local independent watch servicer. Someone here might be able to recommend a local watch person. Good luck.

I'll PM you some recommended places, but a search on Google for "vintage rolex service"

 
 By: Ed. W : September 21st, 2016-07:22
will yield plenty of forum answers. And also yes, don't replace or repair any external parts (dial, case, crown, hands, etc.)

Aftermarket service. Replace as little as possible. Don't polish.

 
 By: cazalea : September 21st, 2016-10:38
It should be no major challenge to a good independent. Mike

I don't think you should worry about the value

 
 By: Harry2 : September 21st, 2016-11:47
It is possible a movement part will need replacement and I know vintage Rolex pieces do come back from Rolex unmolested sometimes. However, I have heard horror stories. I think the number one priority should be that the watch is in great shape and running... 

If the watch is running why touch. Enjoy it and wait till starts to lose time.

 
 By: Bill : September 21st, 2016-11:48
Service at a qualified vintage service house that know Rolex. Not Rolex service center. Replace nothing. Anything you replace will diminish the value significantly.

First enjoy it. Learn about it and what it needs.

 
 By: Bill : September 21st, 2016-17:14
Every time a watch is opened you take risk. No rush. What if you don't love it you would have spent hundreds to just pit in a drawer. A nice vintage brown strap would look great on it. Bill ...  

Nice period strap

 
 By: dominic.salter : September 22nd, 2016-02:28
Your strap does suit the this watch very well. My dad had a springy metal strap but it isn't a Rolex strap. I didn't like it much so I replaced it with the leather one. I have an Omega with a metal strap and a Vacheron with brown strap so I chose black to... 

Here are some example of what can work.

 
 By: Bill : September 22nd, 2016-12:16
This style is easily found with varying quality and price. Bill ...  

It depends on how you want the watch serviced

 
 By: jayeyedoubleemmwhy : September 21st, 2016-21:20
Do you want to honor the history/sentimentality of the watch, keeping it as original as possible? Or, do you want to be more aggressive with a service and have a watch that is "newer" (manufacturer's guarantee, water resistance, etc.)? Both have their pro... 

Thanks for the detailed reply

 
 By: dominic.salter : September 22nd, 2016-02:47
I am glad I posted on this site as everyone has been very kind in giving me lots of good information and your long reply is very informative. Cosmetically the watch doesn't need anything doing except the hands could be tided up and re-lumed but given the ... 

Local repairer

 
 By: chippytime : September 22nd, 2016-04:19
Please see my PM Best Clive