Only with . . .

Sep 23, 2014,13:24 PM
 

. . . clenched teeth!


smile

The short version of the long story is that I acquired a '50 IWC cal 89 from a reputable source who acknowledged the watch needed servicing, and priced it accordingly.  The first watchmaker found a problem with the seconds pinion, but apparently resorted to a 'work-around' to get the movement running instead of sourcing a replacement.  After wearing it for only a day, I noticed the seconds hand wouldn't advance beyond the 50 second mark without faltering every third minute or so.   It was only in retrospect that I learned the reason: seconds pinions are about as rare as hen's teeth.  The second watchmaker also tried but was unable to get it running, so I was forced to scour the internet in search of a seconds pinion.  I finally found one in Germany.



[original seconds pinion above, nos replacement below]

Finally, after well over a year between two watchmakers, it was running with a properly advancing seconds hand.   Unfortunately, it was running about half a minute per day slow in my timing tests.  Back to the watchmaker.  Finally, after many months, came the answer: the minute wheel was heavily worn, and beyond repair.  

I must've spent twenty hours scouring the internet and communicating with parts suppliers.  Finally, a minute wheel was found on a German website, and my watchmaker placed an order.  The minute wheel didn't arrive.  He placed a second order.  Still, no minute wheel.  He called the supplier, and you guessed it: they were looking for a minute wheel to fulfill the order!  They had a picture up on their website, and a price, too, but apparently never had the part in stock.

Fortunately, the seller made up for the defective IWC with a perfectly sound Omega in trade.  I lost out financially, undoubtedly, and had a good chunk of funds tied up for three years while attempting to revive a corpse.  Oh, yes; the IWC was actually running when I traded it back to the seller, but it stopped a week later.  

At least it's out of my hair now.  

Relieved,

Art

 



This message has been edited by Dr No on 2014-09-23 14:37:07

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Rating of vintage watches in market

 
 By: RDL : September 18th, 2014-07:25
To the communiy: Triggered by looking at Zenith vintage watches recently, I was debating with myself if/how under-valued Zenith watches (especially El Primeros) are compared to others. So I tried to assess 'how under-valued'...leading to thinking about ot... 

You forgot some great ones, like Tissot and most of all, Lemania. ;)

 
 By: amanico : September 18th, 2014-07:38
Leroy, too... And what about Minerva? Blancpain? Tudor? It is impossible to answer to your question, for me. Why? Because some specific watches in each of these brands have more value watches from other : A Longines 13 ZN mushroom pushers, black dial is a... 

+1, where do we stop?

 
 By: ztirual : September 18th, 2014-14:01
We'll said Nico! Big differences within a make, within a model and even within a case reference, just I illustrate the 13ZN example... Then we have to take into account the condition of the watch... Where do we stop? Are Renault cars from 1940-70 cheaper ... 

I must confess that I know almost nothing about the Citroen and Renault prod from these

 
 By: amanico : September 18th, 2014-14:10
Years, but I get your idea very well. ;) Yes, too many factors, détails, to make a solid statement. But we can already say that there is a serious life outside the usual suspects ( Patek / Rolex / Panerai ( Vintage ) / and so on ), and that the outsiders ... 

Your last remark..

 
 By: ztirual : September 18th, 2014-14:41
Just my thoughts! You already said enough when mentioning Tissot & Lemania... ;-)

i'll play

 
 By: eterna-fan : September 18th, 2014-17:11
- Zenith - 6. i think the more average vintage pieces are elevated by the excellent chronographs and the 135. - Movado - 4. very good quality. vintage collectors don't seem to love them enough. - Omega - 7. although it is a brand i love, the current price... 

I certainly can't argue with you about Eterna.

 
 By: mkvc : September 18th, 2014-22:52
A vintage Eterna is always a pleasure. I can't comment on all the brands proposed by RDL, but I have a few comments, each of which illustrates the difficulty of making this type of evaluation: 1. In the top tier, AP and Vacheron are very good values compa... 

great points MKVC

 
 By: RDL : September 19th, 2014-00:37
Very good points. Fully agree on Rolex, although most say over-valued (see my rating below), I also think one has to see Rolex differently. As an investment which so far has never disappointed. So, 'the market' is getting it right then. But, still, for my... 

well

 
 By: eterna-fan : September 19th, 2014-13:28
i wouldn't say that vintage IWC are given away. but again, i am working in a realm that most posters here would consider bottom feeding. i have purchased some very beautiful vintage watches. they are true manufacture movements that represent excellent hor... 

here my take

 
 By: RDL : September 19th, 2014-00:32
First, thanks for playing Eterna-Fan and understanding the spirit of my question. Obviously, such a question is always 'too general' because ultimately you have to go to the level of an individual watch to assess it's value (condition etc.). But, again ,t... 

variations within brands

 
 By: eterna-fan : September 19th, 2014-13:51
i enjoy this sort of discussion. i realize its futility, but as a admirer of all levels of quality and prestige, it gives me a rare opportunity to engage in this wonderful community. some responses to a few of your comments: 1. Zenith - 4 for El Primeros,... 

Good points

 
 By: RDL : September 20th, 2014-05:17
Eterna Fan, interesting points! I also enjoy this discussion and also prefer it to simply posting watch photos. You have made me rethink: I have a extensive Zenith Cal 135 collection but bought most many years ago at much lower price levels. So my view mi... 

I can't believe I missed this thread . . .

 
 By: Dr No : September 21st, 2014-13:44
. . . until just now. :-) This is the sort of discussion we should be having more often. Thanks very much, R, for initiating it. As for my purely subjective opinion, the two manufacturers whose vintage products are trading for substantially a different am... 

Art....you are making me smile!

 
 By: Baron - Mr Red : September 22nd, 2014-02:39

Omeeeegahhh . . .

 
 By: Dr No : September 22nd, 2014-03:35
. . . Omeeeegahhh ;-) . . .

Oh.....me.....ga(nna) get some

 
 By: Baron - Mr Red : September 22nd, 2014-03:37

That's . . .

 
 By: Dr No : September 22nd, 2014-03:41
. . . the spirit! :-)

good points Art!

 
 By: RDL : September 23rd, 2014-02:55
Art, apologies for not responding earlier and thanks a lot for chiming in! BTW: I always enjoy your insightful posts in the different threads here in this great forum. I appreciate your thoughts and find your points very valid. Especially as a chronometer... 

IWC

 
 By: RDL : September 23rd, 2014-02:58
Art, can yo explain a bit more your IWC experience? Was it a problem to find spare parts? I do like the 666/866 Ingenieurs, and a couple of 854x movement models.

Only with . . .

 
 By: Dr No : September 23rd, 2014-13:24
. . . clenched teeth! The short version of the long story is that I acquired a '50 IWC cal 89 from a reputable source who acknowledged the watch needed servicing, and priced it accordingly. The first watchmaker found a problem with the seconds pinion, but...  

maintenance

 
 By: eterna-fan : September 24th, 2014-08:32
i think this the pivotal point behind vintage collecting now. for instance, in my small, northern california town, there used to be a handful of watch repairmen. now, there are only two- and both have issues that make them less than attractive opitions. i... 

LOL. Wise words! [nt]

 
 By: amanico : September 24th, 2014-09:04