Hi George...

Feb 14, 2012,09:48 AM
 

...You are another one for the physical experience connection.  smile  There is no arguing that it's the best way to enjoy a watch. Thanks!

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

What determines the longevity of a watch within a collection?

 
 By: pingtsai : January 31st, 2012-21:10
There is a question that I have been contemplating for a long time – What distinguishes a watch that is kept from one that is sold? To put it another way, what exactly determines the longevity of a watch within an individual's collection? I have seen watc...  

Interesting theory!

 
 By: KIH : January 31st, 2012-22:30
Thanks for the thesis and I agree most of the points. Interesting analogy about watch vs woman (or man). And of course, the emotional attachment. I have bunch of cheapy almost junk watches my father left and they will, I swear, stay with me forever. I had... 

Hi Ken!

 
 By: pingtsai : February 1st, 2012-20:43
That's great about the Timex. I still have my first Swatches Thanks for your comments.

excellent read

 
 By: glorygunners : February 1st, 2012-00:12
I will be sure to remember the above points before making any future purchases... Thanks for this excellent read... Cheers, GG

Thanks for reading... [nt]

 
 By: pingtsai : February 1st, 2012-20:47
No message body

Great article, Ping!

 
 By: dxboon : February 1st, 2012-00:26
Every time I read one of your articles, I'm floored by your flowing prose. Really, you are one of our great writers, regardless of subject! Kudos on that. Returning to the subject at hand, I think turnover has a lot to do with several factors facing the c... 

Thank you Daos....

 
 By: pingtsai : February 1st, 2012-20:54
....for your comments about my writing. That really means so much to me, especially coming from you, a superb writer in your own right. You make some great points...ones that I didn't think of. Thank you!

Another superbly written article, Ping.

 
 By: amanico : February 1st, 2012-00:51
And very interesting topic... I strongly believe that you buy a watch for yourself, not according to others opinions. Don't get me wrong: Others opinions and posts may allow you to discover a watch, then to test it according to your own criterias and tast... 

+1 In complete agreement...

 
 By: patrick_y : February 1st, 2012-09:59
In complete agreement (as usual). To extend one of the points you brought up, we buy watches for ourselves... Not for others... I would even go as far as discouraging the solicitation of other people's opinions, especially those who you do not know person... 

Thanks for your kind words, Patrick.

 
 By: amanico : February 1st, 2012-11:01
Yes, you can be assured that this is an endless love story with the 5110P... You know, when your heart beats faster when you have this one on the wrist, this is a sign... A good and strong one. Best, Nicolas

Hello Nicholas!

 
 By: pingtsai : February 1st, 2012-20:57
Your comments are superbly insightful. Thank you for sharing them. It was precisely my intention to draw out all these angles of thought. Thanks again!

For me, the main factor is knowledge...

 
 By: sidneyc : February 1st, 2012-01:25
Firstly, Ping, thanks for such a great read! It's a thought provoking article and there are lots of wisdom in it! Thank you for sharing that! In response to the question "What determines the longevity of a watch within a collection?", I must agree that wh... 

Another excellent point....

 
 By: pingtsai : February 1st, 2012-20:59
....yes, our tastes change as our knowledge grows. That would have been my next bullet point. Thank you!

An eloquently written article Ping...

 
 By: samwan : February 1st, 2012-02:18
that offers serious food for thought for all watch afficiondos, horology nuts and Purists alike. I cannot agree more with what you said but allow me to add my two cents worth: People's tastes may develop and change over time One day a certain piece may si... 

Hi Sam!

 
 By: pingtsai : February 1st, 2012-21:02
Again....3 very good points. I think my article could have been twice as long. Thank you for your comments.

Great article. It makes me wonder ...

 
 By: nilomis : February 1st, 2012-07:26
Background I started accumulating watches following a set of not so rational reasons but the mainly one was that a mechanical watch is something, in most of cases, produced to last. Since my business (IT) flows around things that are designed to be obsole... 

Hi Nilo...

 
 By: pingtsai : February 1st, 2012-21:06
....very interesting perspective that you have. I have been noticing my tastes have also been veering more towards the conventional, safe, predictable...whatever you may call it . Sometimes when life gets complicated, I find it easier to simplify my physi... 

A watch must endure the owner's changing tastes...

 
 By: patrick_y : February 1st, 2012-09:51
A question worth a deep conversation. In order for a watch to survive one's collection; it must be purchased with a sound mind, not a mind of buying the watch because it was "hot" when it came out. The individuals who buy watches because they were hot com... 

Slow to jump ...

 
 By: AndrewD : February 1st, 2012-15:34
Good points, Patrick. I never place orders for the latest releases. There are always watches that catch my eye from SIHH, or whatever fair has recently occurred, but I tend to wait years before I commit. A

I predict that many who do place their orders prematurely end up regretting...

 
 By: patrick_y : February 1st, 2012-18:22
There are some watches that debut with so much hype that people get excited and buy it. Later losing that excitement. When the Zeitwerk from Lange debuted, I knew I loved it. And have been trying to procure one since.

I share the same feeling Patrick

 
 By: moc : February 1st, 2012-22:46
about the ZW...one day,one day..... Mo

I hope that we both get our watches someday...

 
 By: patrick_y : February 1st, 2012-23:53
I hope that we both get our watches someday. In the meanwhile, I don't blame you if you think about tattooing one onto your wrist!

Ha ha...yes but what time?

 
 By: moc : February 1st, 2012-23:58
At least it will be right twice a day! WG for you Patrick? Mo

Hopefully soon...

 
 By: patrick_y : February 2nd, 2012-08:44
I really like the platinum version... Unfortunately, a big client was ahead of me at the AD. He wasn't that thrilled about the watch initially; and I drove him home from a watch event so he wouldn't have gotten lost in a cab. During the drive I mentioned ... 

Wow Patrick....

 
 By: pingtsai : February 1st, 2012-21:09
.....very insightful. Really appreciate you expressing your thoughts on this topic. I will need to digest some more Thank you!!

Always a pleasure...

 
 By: patrick_y : February 1st, 2012-23:52
Always a pleasure to share my thoughts with you. And thank you for posting this provoking and insightful question! Bottom line, the wearer has to be in love with the watch long after the "hype" has dissipated. Watches that truly pass the test of time are ... 

Thank you.

 
 By: patrick_y : February 2nd, 2012-08:45
If it's not on your wrist, it's difficult to enjoy. If you're not enjoying it, it's that much harder to be in love with it. Classic pieces really last and stand the test of time. The trick is finding one that is a classic but fun piece.

Very Well Said - Patrick

 
 By: markieesq : February 3rd, 2012-14:15
Hello Patrick: Very well said. I really enjoyed reading your very enlightened post. It struck a chord for me. The last time we saw each other was when you mysteriously appeared from thin air at the Lange Exhibition in NYC. Take care, until we meet again. ... 

My warmest wishes to you as well...

 
 By: patrick_y : February 3rd, 2012-21:16
It was such a pleasure to see you and Josh last October. I still have to say, I am so happy for you regarding your new acquisition; every time I look at that watch and I realize it is a great balance of style, fun, and practicality. Definitely a keeper; a... 

Nice post :)

 
 By: emcquillan : February 1st, 2012-10:22
Timeless aesthetic and mechanical elegance are what has stayed in my collection, but this is all subjective. I used to have high turnover with changing moods and desires, but now I buy very selectively. I buy only what I love not just like and keep only w... 

Yes....timeless is key

 
 By: pingtsai : February 1st, 2012-21:11
I completely agree, not just with watches either. It's with everything. Thank you for your comments!

Great post.

 
 By: ingmar : February 1st, 2012-11:15
And wonderful read. Thanks do much. I'm a flip addict and have, more than once, bought the same watch twice.

Lol, that's funny. Thanks for reading... [nt]

 
 By: pingtsai : February 1st, 2012-21:12
No message body

Wow that was a fabulous read!

 
 By: AnthonyTsai : February 1st, 2012-11:29
And yes, you are right about that certain legendary Panerai. I'm glad it's not gone Cheers, Anthony

So am I.... [nt]

 
 By: pingtsai : February 1st, 2012-21:12
No message body

As taste becomes more focused or sophisticated...

 
 By: Stefan2 : February 1st, 2012-11:58
Terrific article! In my experience, as my watch knowledge and experience became more refined, my collecting became more focused on my tastes and preferences. So for me, my collection has become a better expression of my preferences and my deeper knowledge... 

Growing knowledge along with....

 
 By: pingtsai : February 1st, 2012-21:16
...sophistication in taste seems to be a reoccurring theme that I did not think of. Thank you for pointing it out.

very good read

 
 By: donizetti : February 1st, 2012-12:07
I think I will refer back to it as I learn ... until now, I am only sure about the pieces with sentimental value. Most of my current watches I love and cannot see parting with, but I have lost interest in hobbies before and switched to something else ....... 

Eh, no worries....

 
 By: pingtsai : February 2nd, 2012-20:30
....There's enough going on in this industry that I'm sure it will hold your interest

This subject could be the foundation for a . . .

 
 By: Dr No : February 1st, 2012-13:00
. . . dissertation in philosophy: the phenomenology of watch collecting! Aside from the answers already offered, there's another aspect to this question that resides deep within our psyches. My take is that aspects of design resonate (or not) with our sub... 

Indeed, quite the foundation.

 
 By: patrick_y : February 1st, 2012-18:27
That being said, we need to talk again about your collecting philosophy... And the passion and story behind your procurements. All my best to you Art!

Two words come to mind, Patrick: . . .

 
 By: Dr No : February 3rd, 2012-00:20
. . . exit strategy !

Hmm...interesting idea!

 
 By: pingtsai : February 2nd, 2012-20:36
....think I'd have fun with that one. Very intuitively put Art, had to read a couple of times Thanks...

the ineffable

 
 By: cuibono : February 1st, 2012-15:14
i have strong emotional attachments to all my watches. like any relationship, these attachments get stronger or weaker over time, but with time, the weaker become stronger and vice versa. my glasshutte sport evo just caught my eye at first sight and i lov... 

Indeed art...

 
 By: pingtsai : February 2nd, 2012-20:41
...but I guess you'd have to have a taste for the art. Thank you for your comments.

My thoughts ...

 
 By: AndrewD : February 1st, 2012-15:37
Watches are a blend of likes and dislikes; features and compromises for the individual wearer. And circumstances, knowledge and preferences change over time. But even if some watches get less wrist time than they first did, I enjoy their place in my colle... 

I couldn't agree more...

 
 By: pingtsai : February 3rd, 2012-18:22
...about little characteristics about the watch only exposed during wear. That is why "on the wrist" reviews are so important in getting a more comprehensive look at the watch. I like your thread topic idea. Maybe for the next one. Thanks Andrew!

Excellent post

 
 By: aldossari_faisal : February 1st, 2012-16:36
and a neat subject... Ill get back to it with my personal opinion. Faisal

Cool! Looking forward to it. [nt]

 
 By: pingtsai : February 3rd, 2012-18:23
No message body

Fantastic write up Ping!

 
 By: BluNotte : February 1st, 2012-16:44
I can see who and which watch you are relating to in the article! Glad it worked out for you and Anths! Congrats as always on your husband's special grail! Have yet to see it in reality, but hopefully one day! Cheers Stephen

Thank you Stephen! [nt]

 
 By: pingtsai : February 3rd, 2012-18:26
No message body

Thank you for this eloquent piece

 
 By: Ginger : February 1st, 2012-16:50
I am not sure what it is about a watch that makes it special. Often it is not possible to know at the moment of purchase, even if we have been often to the dealer and done all our research. After all, most of us have dated someone seriously for quite a wh... 

Thank you Ginger for your elegant response.

 
 By: pingtsai : February 3rd, 2012-18:29
I find it fascinating how watches and relationships have so many parallels. Guess it makes it all the more fun

Great questions, and all interesting hypotheses

 
 By: Gary G : February 1st, 2012-19:52
Great OP, and very interesting thread so far! My guess is that any and all of the root causes set forward by various posters apply to many individuals. For me, the one that really rings true is that the more striking the watch is (in unconventional visibl... 

Subdials!

 
 By: AndrewD : February 1st, 2012-20:39
I realised Gary, that I like subdials, be they Journe-inspired or chronographs. I have been drawn the Lange 1 Moonphase for years for the same reason, but it's just the movement that puts me off committing. So it seems that these are the visual cues that ...  

Thank you Gary for all your personal examples.

 
 By: pingtsai : February 3rd, 2012-18:32
They really do illustrate well the ideas I was trying to set forth. Thanks!

Watch collecting is a difficult hobby because of the points you have

 
 By: watch-guy.com : February 1st, 2012-20:25
highlighted. This is a great discussion 1. There is no question that the quest far outshines the conquest in most ases. I have experienced this many times in the past but have not sold off anything after the glow has gone 2.The more I wear a watch, the mo... 

Hi Julian,

 
 By: pingtsai : February 11th, 2012-14:20
Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I'm glad that you agree with me on the points There is nothing wrong with holding on to your watches. Perhaps you are one who doesn't let go easily Happy collecting and thanks again.

This is a great topic and something I have thought

 
 By: docsnov : February 1st, 2012-21:19
about quite a bit in the last 2 years. A number of the watches I have were bought on impulse without taking a long time to think about the purchase. I think with any new purchase there is the initial excitement of having a new piece, and it typically gets... 

Absolutely agree...

 
 By: pingtsai : February 11th, 2012-14:39
...that watches do not need to be worn in order to be kept. Otherwise, most collections would need to remain quite small. There's only so many days in a week, a month etc. The vast majority probably aren't. Thank you for your comments.

Thank you Anthony!

 
 By: George Ab : February 1st, 2012-23:02
Exceptionally thoughtful and a provocative. Thank you for the effort you put into this. I truly enjoyed the read and am soaking this in. George

Hey...I wrote it, the smarter Tsai here :) lol [nt]

 
 By: pingtsai : February 11th, 2012-14:42
No message body

You must be referring to me then! :) [nt]

 
 By: AnthonyTsai : February 11th, 2012-14:51
No message body

Not even close :P [nt]

 
 By: pingtsai : February 11th, 2012-14:54
No message body

Dear Ping you hit that nail right on the head..

 
 By: moc : February 1st, 2012-23:04
The essence of our hobby,the true spirit of it. Never believe any watch fan telling you that its over,or that after that watch the collection will be complete or done.A watch collection is always in a slow movement. As a relative newbie in the game,I tend... 

Hi Mo...yes, it does take time...

 
 By: pingtsai : February 11th, 2012-14:52
...to build a collection and even then, it will always be changing because we are always changing, kind of the beauty of it. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

I could have written this :)

 
 By: Mark in Paris : February 2nd, 2012-03:36
I completly agree and I would add that I think there exists no miraculous recipe. Taking time, seeing more and more watches before a purchase helps collecting datas about our tastes, understanding what we like and what we don't, and helps mitigate the ris... 

Hi Mark...

 
 By: pingtsai : February 11th, 2012-20:50
....I agree that research and especially trying a watch on on person is very important in minimizing buyer's remorse, short or long term. But what about those times when you are up and there's a long list of names behind you who are ready to pull out thei... 

Emotion connection sums it up!

 
 By: patrickmaniac : February 2nd, 2012-05:43
cheers PAt

Thought provoking and beautifully written. There is only one watch

 
 By: 219 : February 2nd, 2012-07:02
that has stayed with me through the years - and for good reasons. All others have come and gone; usually a spur of the moment purchase that I later wondered about. For me, the one watch is: http://jlc.watchprosite.com/show-forumpost/fi-2/pi-4404698/ti-684... 

A great story indeed...

 
 By: pingtsai : February 11th, 2012-22:20
Thank you Andrew for sharing yours. When a watch and an owner are meant to be together as clearly was the case in your situation, I don't think they will ever be separated. Thanks agian.

Unless you buy for investment, it's purely emotional...

 
 By: mrsnak : February 2nd, 2012-09:10
...and emotions will change as you grow and change through life. Other than that, sentimental value would probably remain the most constant reason to keep a watch (no matter the value), whether it belonged to a cherished family member or was part of the "... 

yes...it's all about sentimental value...

 
 By: pingtsai : February 11th, 2012-22:39
...what I was trying to get at was why...why does one watch hold onto sentimental value longer than another one. Thank you for your comments

Fantastic read and thought provoking post!

 
 By: ocwatching : February 2nd, 2012-09:35
I for one tend to have grouped my pieces into two areas. One that stays forever (heirloom) pieces that are associated with significant moments in my/our lives that are marked by a timepiece. These may not be of collector quality but due to its emotional v... 

Thank you!

 
 By: pingtsai : February 14th, 2012-09:32
Very interesting collecting habits Although I'm willing to bet that you are not alone. Maybe that is what keeps it fun. Thanks for your comments!

EITHER True Love OR Inability to sell the darn thing!

 
 By: cazalea : February 2nd, 2012-10:32
Hi Ping I look at other people's collections and look at what happens to their watches. Some turn over regardless of the purchaser. Is it the model? The brand? The fashion trends around us? I don't know. And I look at some specific watches - especially th... 

That's ok...

 
 By: pingtsai : February 14th, 2012-09:36
I have seen and realize that this post has brought out all the different ways that people collect and enjoy their watches. It's very interesting how personal it can be. Thanks for sharing your comments.

Very interestin post

 
 By: mark_third : February 2nd, 2012-12:14
I personally like to buy watches some times after they are released because I need to understand fully the watch before buying it. After this I always find myself discovering new things after several months. I really try to avoid the "brand new" effect.

Hi Mark....

 
 By: pingtsai : February 14th, 2012-09:37
...very smart and great control on your part Thanks!

Sometimes it may be the WRIST TIME!

 
 By: anaesdoc : February 2nd, 2012-15:32
Hi Ping, thank you for your interesting question and some observations you made while answering it for yourself. My headline seems to be a tautology, because a watch you like will be regularly worn and stay in your collection. But I have observed that a w... 

You make such a great point...

 
 By: pingtsai : February 14th, 2012-09:40
...The physical experience of a watch is definitely a big part of connecting with it. For it is sometimes moving the senses that gets us the most. Thanks!

I really enjoyed reading this post....

 
 By: David Elliott : February 2nd, 2012-18:23
Ping, I can relate to each of the points you raised. Sometimes the journey (searching for the watch) is more fun than the destination (getting it). Thanks again for sharing. Dave

Thank you Dave! [nt]

 
 By: pingtsai : February 14th, 2012-09:41
No message body

Enjoyed your post very much Ping

 
 By: dreamer8 : February 2nd, 2012-22:57
My collection shows no rhyme or reason . Some pieces I buy because of pedigree, Some I buy on a whim and they are still keepers.Some are keepers because of emotional attachment. I tend to be a hoarder and have sought advice from a few here on how to overc... 

LOL....

 
 By: pingtsai : February 14th, 2012-09:43
...There can be beauty in chaos as well..."There is always something about dreaming...."

For sure

 
 By: Albert.J : February 3rd, 2012-05:42
Sometimes, especially when there's a extreme rare and coveted watch, people 'TRY TO LOVE' it even if it actually does not look good to them. Because if you buy it, everyone will envy and pay attention to your watch. And there would be many other reasons a... 

Hi Albert...

 
 By: pingtsai : February 14th, 2012-09:46
...I think we have all experienced the case of trying to "fit a square peg in a round hole." ...trying to fit ourselves to something or someone instead of finding the right thing that fits us. I'm glad you realized this Thanks for sharing.

For me it's all wrist time related.

 
 By: grigo : February 3rd, 2012-20:43
Probably for all the reasons that you mentioned in your post. The only reason for me to keep a watch that is not getting enough wrist time is because it has sentimental value and as a result it is impossible to part with. One other reason that I have seen... 

Hi George...

 
 By: pingtsai : February 14th, 2012-09:48
...You are another one for the physical experience connection. There is no arguing that it's the best way to enjoy a watch. Thanks!

I could not agree more!

 
 By: big daddy : February 8th, 2012-10:54
Great post and very thought provoking as all of which you mentioned has happened to me. When I reached your comments about emotional attachments, I understood. Never say never, there are 3 watches I probably will never sell and I have even thought who I w... 

Well thank you for agreeing...

 
 By: pingtsai : February 14th, 2012-09:56
...It is never necessary for anyone other than yourself to see or know why a watch means something to you. Just the fact that you met with the watchmaker to discuss the watch is already enough to make it special. It wouldn't even matter if the watch was e... 

Watches with significance...

 
 By: patrick_y : February 14th, 2012-09:59
Indeed. Watches with significance will always be with us, as the story behind the piece makes the piece too sentimental to ever part with. All the best!

Interesting and perceptive post

 
 By: halkcb : February 9th, 2012-04:50
Thanks for a very illuminating post---agree with much of your sentiments However, the reasons i've kept most ,if not all of my watches, is due to the length of the search for a particular piece and/or the memories attached to certain purchases. Sentiment ... 

Thank you for your two bits....

 
 By: pingtsai : February 14th, 2012-09:58
...good point about maintenance costs. I didn't even think about that. That definitely is a factor in keeping anything. Thanks again for sharing.

Thank you Ping for this fantastic & thought provoking post...

 
 By: Subexplorer : February 11th, 2012-16:46
... it invites you to think about what makes a watch to be declared "a keeper". It has been said that the search, the find, and the more or less complicated events which led to the "capture" of a new piece, is the most exciting part of the "art of collect... 

Thank you Abel...

 
 By: pingtsai : February 14th, 2012-10:02
...You are right that it appears to be a process. Whether each watch passes and moves on to the second part of the process of connecting determines whether it stays or goes. There's a threshold and the makeup of that "threshold" is different for everyone.... 

This is not a watch question!

 
 By: botate : February 22nd, 2012-15:15
This is a human nature question. Rule 1) we covet what we either cannot get or is very difficult to come by Rule 2)usually...after a certain period of time...no matter what it is...the novelty wears off Rule 3)this also applies to women.....but not dogs R... 

Hi Robert...

 
 By: pingtsai : February 23rd, 2012-14:46
Thank you for your comments. You are so right...so much of our "human nature" tendencies are tied into our watch collecting habits. We could easily apply the question to another topic and have the same results. Thanks again and sorry about the women

Interesting Thoughts

 
 By: tgator96 : February 24th, 2012-06:53
For me, two factors have been the most significant in determining the longevity of a timepiece in my collection--sentiment and changing tastes. Some pieces I hope to never part with like the watch my parents gave me when I graduated college. For others, a... 

I have a lot of introspective time, betwen you and Marcus' post about Teflon watches. ;)

 
 By: amanico : January 25th, 2013-19:41
It is the middle of the night, here in Paris, and the house is quiet, so I have the time to think about it... I have a lot of watches which are in my collection for some very long years, and I don't sell more than one to three watches per year, from my pe...